MaizePrepECON 102
Midterm 2 · M2 · 1

National saving & S = I

Saving is this period’s income not spent on C or G. In a closed economy it equals investment, and the real interest rate makes savers and investors agree.

22 min

Build the model

Macro saving is this period’s income that is not consumed. Money already sitting in a bank account is savings, a stock, and is not this year’s saving. Moving old money from a deposit into a bond swaps one financial asset for another: it is neither saving nor investment. Spending old savings on consumption is negative saving.

Add and subtract taxes to split national saving into private saving Y−T−CY-T-C and public saving T−GT-G, the budget surplus. A deficit makes public saving negative, which is the usual case for the US. Business profit is income too, so a firm that spends its own profit on a new machine saves and invests in one act.

In a closed economy Y=C+I+GY=C+I+G, so S=Y−C−G=IS=Y-C-G=I. That identity does not explain how the two decisions match. If desired saving exceeds desired investment, banks hold deposits they cannot lend at a profit, so they cut rates: saving falls and investment rises until they are equal. If investment exceeds saving, rates rise.

Key ideas

National saving

S=Y−C−GS=Y-C-G: income in the period not spent on private or government consumption.

Saving versus savings

Saving is this period’s flow; savings is the accumulated stock of wealth.

Example A household that starts the year with 1 million in the bank, earns 100,000 and spends 80,000 saved 20,000 this year.

Private saving

Y−T−CY-T-C: after-tax income not consumed. Retained business profit counts, because profit is income.

Public saving

T−GT-G, the budget surplus. A deficit (G>TG>T) makes it negative.

Consumer borrowing

Borrowing to finance consumption is negative saving. It is not demand for loanable funds, which is desired investment only.

Closed-economy identity

S=IS=I: what a closed economy saves equals what it invests. The real interest rate brings the two desires into line.

Formulas

National saving
S=Y−C−GS=Y-C-G
T is not in this expression. A tax change affects S only through C.
Private plus public
S=(Y−T−C)+(T−G)S=(Y-T-C)+(T-G)
T means taxes net of transfers.
Closed economy
Y=C+I+G  ⇒  S=IY=C+I+G\;\Rightarrow\;S=I
An identity; equilibrium in the loanable-funds market explains how it comes about.
An income-tax increase with G unchanged: households cut C by only part of the tax, so national saving rises at every r. S shifts right, the real rate falls from r₀ to r₁, and investment rises along unchanged I.
Worked example

Split national saving

A closed economy has Y = 5,000, C = 3,300, taxes net of transfers T = 900 and government purchases G = 1,050. Find private, public and national saving and investment. Then let G rise by 100, financed by borrowing, with Y, C and T unchanged.

  1. Private saving: Y−T−C=5,000−900−3,300=800Y-T-C=5{,}000-900-3{,}300=800.

  2. Public saving: T−G=900−1,050=−150T-G=900-1{,}050=-150, a deficit of 150.

  3. National saving: 800+(−150)=650800+(-150)=650, the same as Y−C−G=5,000−3,300−1,050Y-C-G=5{,}000-3{,}300-1{,}050.

  4. Closed economy, so investment I=S=650I=S=650.

  5. With G = 1,150, public saving is −250-250 and national saving is 550550: at every real rate, 100 less is supplied to the loanable-funds market.

Answer

Private 800, public −150, national 650 = I. The borrowing-financed rise in G cuts national saving to 550.

Is it saving, and which way does S move?

Income tax rises and the question does not mention G
Assume G is unchanged. C falls by less than the tax, so national saving rises: S shifts right.
Government purchases rise with taxes unchanged
Public saving falls one for one: S shifts left.
A household moves old savings from a deposit into a bond
No saving and no investment: one asset is swapped for another.
A firm spends this year’s profit on new equipment
Saving and investment at once; no bank or bond market is involved.
Households borrow to buy furniture or vacations
Negative saving: S shifts left. It is not demand for loanable funds.

Six-question check

1
National saving & S = I

A closed economy has Y = 2,400, C = 1,560, G = 420 and taxes net of transfers T = 380. What is national saving? Enter a whole number.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.
2
National saving & S = I

Which of these add to this year’s national saving? Select all that apply.

3
National saving & S = I

A corporation earns a profit of 500. It pays 200 as dividends, which shareholders spend entirely on consumption, and keeps 300 to build a new warehouse. What are the effects on national saving and investment?

4
National saving & S = I

At the current real interest rate in a closed economy, households want to save 900 while firms want to invest 750. What happens next?

5
National saving & S = I

At the start of the year a household has 50,000 in the bank. During the year it earns 70,000 after taxes and spends 64,000. What is its saving for the year? Enter a whole number.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.
6
National saving & S = I

A question says only that “the government raises the income tax.” For this course, what should you assume about government purchases G, and what happens to public saving?

MaizePrep is an independent study resource. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the University of Michigan. Course names and numbers are used only to describe which class the material covers. Every practice question is original, written in the style of the course.