MaizePrepECON 102
Final · Segment 3 · 6

Debt, deficits & policy tradeoffs

The deficit is a flow; debt is a stock. Judge borrowing by its use, the economic conditions, and debt relative to the resources available to service it.

25 minDraft

Build the model

A total deficit includes interest spending. The primary deficit excludes it. In a simplified government budget without asset sales or valuation changes, this year’s total deficit adds to the debt stock. A country can have rising debt in dollars but a falling debt-to-GDP ratio if nominal GDP grows faster.

Borrowing can cushion a recession or finance valuable public investment; persistent borrowing at full capacity can reduce national saving and private capital accumulation. Future taxes, interest costs, and fiscal flexibility matter. Neither “all borrowing is harmful” nor “borrowing has no cost” follows from these models.

Key ideas

Budget deficit

Spending exceeding revenue during a period; a flow. Specify whether interest is included.

Government debt

Outstanding accumulated borrowing at a point in time; a stock.

Primary balance

Revenue minus noninterest spending; a primary surplus can coexist with a total deficit.

Debt-to-GDP ratio

Debt divided by annual GDP, a scale comparison useful for assessing repayment capacity.

Cyclical deficit

The portion associated with the business cycle, such as reduced tax receipts during a recession.

Public investment tradeoff

Borrowing can create productive assets, but projects must be evaluated against financing costs and displaced private uses.

Formulas

Debt accumulation
Bt=Bt−1+DtB_t=B_{t-1}+D_t
D is the total deficit including interest; ignores valuation changes and financial-asset transactions.
Total versus primary deficit
Dt=PDt+itBt−1D_t=PD_t+i_tB_{t-1}
PD is the primary deficit, positive for noninterest spending above revenue.
Debt ratio dynamics
bt=1+it1+gtbt−1+pdtb_t=\frac{1+i_t}{1+g_t}b_{t-1}+pd_t
g is nominal GDP growth; pd is primary deficit/current GDP. Do not mix nominal i with real g.
At fixed long-run output, lower national saving shifts S left. Real interest rises and private investment falls in the closed-economy model.
Worked example

Debt rises while its ratio falls

Initial debt is 600 and nominal GDP is 1,000. The total annual deficit is 24 and nominal GDP grows 6%. Ignore valuation changes.

  1. New debt is 600+24=624600+24=624.

  2. New nominal GDP is 1,000(1.06)=1,0601,000(1.06)=1,060.

  3. The ratio changes from 600/1,000=60%600/1,000=60\% to 624/1,060≈58.87%624/1,060\approx58.87\%.

Answer

Debt rises by 24, but debt/GDP falls about 1.13 percentage points. Do not add interest again: the given total deficit includes it.

Shift which curve, which way?

A persistent deficit reduces saving at fixed Y
Loanable-funds S left → r up → private I down.
A recession reduces tax receipts under existing rules
The deficit rises automatically; it is not proof of a new discretionary policy.
Useful infrastructure raises productive capacity over time
LRAS may shift right; evaluate this separately from the immediate AD effect.

Three-question check

1
Debt, deficits & policy tradeoffs

A total deficit falls from 50 to 20. With no other adjustments, debt:

2
Debt, deficits & policy tradeoffs

Debt = 400, interest rate = 5%, and primary surplus = 8. The total deficit is:

3
Debt, deficits & policy tradeoffs

Which statement is sufficient to explain a falling debt ratio despite rising nominal debt?

MaizePrep is an independent study resource. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the University of Michigan. Course names and numbers are used only to describe which class the material covers. Every practice question is original, written in the style of the course.