Many households start financing vacations and furniture with consumer loans. In the loanable-funds model this is:
The loanable-funds market: shifts & crowding out
Supply is desired national saving, demand is desired investment, and the real rate clears the market. Ask which curve shifts before asking where equilibrium goes.
Build the model
Put the real interest rate on the vertical axis and loanable funds per period on the horizontal axis. Supply (desired saving) slopes up because the substitution effect of a better return slightly outweighs the income effect. Demand (desired investment) slopes down because a higher lowers the present value of a project’s future profits; even a firm using its own cash gives up interest it could have earned.
Supply shifts when the ability or the motive to save changes: retirement (the biggest motive), precaution and bequests, plus policy such as taxes on interest income, pension design, estate taxes and budget deficits. Demand shifts with the marginal product of capital: technology, the size and skill of the labor force, regulation and law enforcement, corporate taxes, and Keynes’s “animal spirits.” A mortgage for a newly built house is investment (demand right); buying an existing house changes nothing; a car loan or credit-card balance is negative saving (supply left).
Crowding out: a deficit-financed rise in G lowers national saving, shifts S left, raises and reduces private investment. A deficit from a tax cut also crowds out, but less, because households save part of the cut; a tax-financed rise in G crowds out less still. Infrastructure can raise firms’ MPK and shift demand right, and in a recession more G can “crowd in” investment by raising demand, but at full capacity more G must come out of C or I.
World real interest rates have fallen since the 1980s while world saving stayed near 25% of world GDP, so both curves moved: saving right (longer lives, fewer children, China’s growing share, rising inequality) and investment left (slower growth, a less capital-intensive IT economy, firms’ caution after 2008). The Fed sets short-run rates, but in the long run it must return to the level this market determines.
Key ideas
- Supply of loanable funds
Desired national saving at each real interest rate; slopes up.
- Demand for loanable funds
Desired investment at each real interest rate; slopes down. Consumer loans are not part of it.
- Shift versus movement
A change in a shifter moves a curve; a change in r moves the economy along the curves.
Example New technology shifts demand right; the extra saving that follows is a movement along S.
- Crowding out
Government borrowing lowers national saving, raises r and reduces private investment.
- Crowding in
In a recession, extra government spending can raise demand and make firms willing to invest; at full capacity it cannot.
- The falling real rate
A global decline since the 1980s with a flat world saving share: saving shifted right and investment shifted left.
Formulas
Compare three ways to pay for 100 of government spending
At full employment, compare the change in national saving when (1) G rises by 100 financed by borrowing; (2) G is unchanged but taxes fall by 100 and households spend 60 of the cut; (3) G rises by 100 and taxes rise by 100, and households cut consumption by 60.
Use with Y fixed.
(1) , : .
(2) , : . Private saving rises 40, public saving falls 100.
(3) , : , even though the budget stays balanced.
In every case S shifts left, r rises and investment falls; the shift is largest in (1).
National saving falls by 100, 60 and 40. Borrowing-financed G crowds out the most; a balanced-budget rise in G still crowds out some investment because consumption falls by less than the tax.
Shift which curve, which way?
Six-question check
A breakthrough in battery technology makes new factories more profitable. Compared with the original closed-economy equilibrium:
Which of these shift the supply of loanable funds (desired national saving) to the right? Select all that apply.
World real interest rates have fallen since the 1980s. Which of these reasons from lecture work through the SUPPLY of loanable funds (desired saving) rather than investment demand? Select all that apply.
In a closed economy at full employment, desired saving is and desired investment is , with r in percent. A new budget deficit lowers national saving by 50 at every interest rate. By how much does equilibrium private investment fall? Enter a whole number.
A news report says only that the real interest rate has risen. Which curve in the loanable-funds graph shifted?