Warehouses install robots that make each remaining worker far more productive, and over time firms expand. In the labor-market model, what is the long-run effect?
The labor market: wages and employment
Labor is the one factor set within each period, by supply and demand. Productivity drives labor demand; people’s willingness to work drives labor supply. A change in the wage is a movement along a curve, never a shift.
Build the model
Labor supply (LS) is a function, not a number: how much people want to work at each wage. The substitution effect (leisure gets more expensive) makes it slope up; the income effect (richer people buy more leisure) works against that. If they cancel, LS is vertical; over the last century hours stayed near 40 a week as wages rose, but the course uses an upward-sloping LS for the short run.
Labor demand (LD) slopes down because firms hire until a worker’s extra output falls to the wage, and with capital and technology fixed each extra worker adds less (DMP). The model assumes competitive, wage-taking firms and workers.
At equilibrium everyone who wants to work at has a job. People further along LS would work only at a higher wage: they are voluntarily out of the labor force, not unemployed. The model therefore explains the employed but not unemployment, which needs the “wrinkles” in the next section.
What shifts what: LD moves with productivity (K, A, H), the profitability of hiring (corporate taxes) and destruction of capital. LS moves with the number of people (immigration, a large cohort turning 16, retirements) and the willingness to work (income taxes, since the axis is the pre-tax wage; preferences). How much wages versus employment respond depends on the slopes: with a nearly vertical LS, a demand increase raises wages a lot and employment hardly at all.
Trade moves labor between industries. Apply the same graph to one industry at a time: a firm’s demand for workers comes from the value of what they produce. When a country opens to trade, industries that now face cheaper imports sell less at home, so their LD shifts left (lower wages, fewer jobs there); industries that start exporting sell more, so their LD shifts right (higher wages, more jobs). Over time workers leave the shrinking industry and retrain for the growing one, which shifts LS left in the first and right in the second. The transition is costly for the displaced, which is why the lecture links trade (like technology) to inclusive-growth policies.
Key ideas
- Labor supply
People’s desire to work at each wage. Upward sloping when the substitution effect dominates.
- Labor demand
Firms’ desire to hire at each wage, set by labor’s marginal product. Downward sloping because of DMP.
- Substitution vs. income effect
A higher wage makes leisure costlier (work more) but also makes people richer (want more leisure). The net effect sets the slope of LS.
- Shift vs. movement
A wage change is a movement along a curve. A wage can only rise if LS shifted left or LD shifted right.
- Voluntarily out of the labor force
People who would work only above the going wage. In the classic model they are not unemployed.
- Complementarity of labor and capital
More capital per worker raises labor’s marginal product, so LD shifts right; destroyed capital shifts it left.
Formulas
Two shocks at once
In the same year, a cut in the corporate profit tax makes hiring more profitable, and a large cohort of workers retires. What happens to the equilibrium wage and employment?
Corporate tax cut: firms want more workers at every wage, so LD shifts right. Alone: W up, L up.
Retirements: fewer people want to work at every wage, so LS shifts left. Alone: W up, L down.
Both push the wage up, so W rises for sure.
They push employment in opposite directions, so the change in L depends on the sizes of the shifts.
The wage rises; employment is ambiguous. A clean answer names each curve, its direction, and which result is certain.
Which curve shifts?
Seven-question check
A large wave of immigrants of working age arrives. Holding everything else fixed, what happens?
After a productivity boom raises labor demand in one region, economists observe that real wages rose about 12% while total hours worked barely changed. What does this suggest about labor supply in that region?
Which of these shift labor demand to the right? Select all that apply.
In the same year, a cut in the personal income tax makes people want to work more, and floods destroy part of the capital stock. What happens to the equilibrium wage and employment?
For a group of workers, the income effect of a wage increase exactly offsets the substitution effect. What does their labor supply curve look like, and what follows?
A trade deal shrinks a country’s toy industry, which now faces cheap imports, and expands its medical-device industry, which now exports. Over the following years workers gradually move between the two. Which statements fit the labor-market model for this period of adjustment? Select all that apply.