MaizePrepECON 102
Midterm 1 · M1 · 5

Production, diminishing returns & NDP

Output comes from K, L, H and N, scaled by technology A. Each extra unit of capital adds less, while depreciation grows with K, so piling up capital raises GDP for a while but cannot sustain growth. Poor countries gain the most from it: the catch-up effect.

25 min

Build the model

Factors of production: labor L (hours), physical capital K (structures and equipment), human capital H (skills, knowledge, health), natural resources N. Technology A is not a factor: it is the coefficient that says how much output a bundle of factors yields (total factor productivity). Natural resources matter little for a single country, which can import them.

Hold A, L, H and N fixed and add capital. The first factories are staffed by idle workers and add a lot; later ones find fewer people to work in them. That is diminishing marginal product (DMP): the production curve is concave. Depreciation is a fixed share δ of K, a straight line from the origin. The vertical gap between output and depreciation is NDP. It is largest where one more unit of capital adds exactly as much output as it costs to maintain (MPK=δMPK=\delta); beyond that, extra capital costs more in upkeep than it produces, and at K2K_2 the whole GDP goes to maintenance.

The same logic gives the catch-up effect: a country with little capital has a high MPK and cheap maintenance, so investment raises output a lot (post-war Japan and Germany, China since the late 1970s). As capital piles up, growth slows toward the rate set by technology.

Key ideas

Production function

Y=A⋅F(K,L,H,N)Y=A\cdot F(K,L,H,N): how factors become output. A multiplies everything; raising A raises output with no extra inputs.

Marginal product of capital (MPK)

Extra output from one more unit of capital, other inputs fixed. It falls as K rises (diminishing marginal product).

Diminishing marginal product

Each additional unit of one factor adds less output than the one before. It is about output, not costs, and it applies to every factor.

Depreciation

Capital that wears out or becomes obsolete each period, δK\delta K. No “diminishing depreciation”: it grows in proportion to K.

NDP-maximizing capital

The K where output minus depreciation is largest. Add capital only while MPK>δMPK>\delta.

Catch-up effect

Countries starting with little capital grow faster when they invest, because MPK is high and upkeep is low. It fades as capital accumulates.

Formulas

Production function
Y=A⋅F(K,L,H,N)Y=A\cdot F(K,L,H,N)
Marginal product
MPK=ΔYΔK(others fixed)MPK=\frac{\Delta Y}{\Delta K}\quad(\text{others fixed})
Net domestic product
NDP(K)=A F(K,… )−δKNDP(K)=A\,F(K,\dots)-\delta K
Best capital stock
MPK=δ;for Y=aK:  a2K=δ  ⇒  K∗=(a2δ)2MPK=\delta;\quad\text{for }Y=a\sqrt{K}:\;\frac{a}{2\sqrt{K}}=\delta\;\Rightarrow\;K^*=\Big(\frac{a}{2\delta}\Big)^2
Exams usually give a short list of K values: compute NDP for each and pick the largest.
GDP rises with K at a falling rate; depreciation δK rises in a straight line. NDP, the vertical gap, is largest at K (here K = 576 for GDP = 12√K and δ = 0.25) and falls to zero at K₂, where all output goes to maintenance.
Worked example

Find the best capital stock, then work backward

Output is Y=6KLY=6\sqrt{KL} with L=4L=4, so Y=12KY=12\sqrt{K}. (1) With a quarter of capital depreciating each year, which capital stock maximizes NDP? (2) A planning ministry insists that K = 900 is the best stock. What depreciation rate would have to hold for that to be true?

  1. (1) Marginal rule: MPK=6/KMPK=6/\sqrt{K}. Set it equal to δ=0.25\delta=0.25: K=24\sqrt{K}=24, so K∗=576K^*=576 and NDP=288−144=144NDP=288-144=144.

  2. Check a neighbor on each side: at K = 400, NDP=240−100=140NDP=240-100=140; at K = 900, NDP=360−225=135NDP=360-225=135. Both are lower.

  3. (2) Work backward: for 900 to be best, MPKMPK at 900 must equal δ. MPK=6/30=0.2MPK=6/30=0.2, so δ would have to be 20%.

  4. With δ = 0.2, NDP at 900 is 360−180=180360-180=180, higher than at 576 (288−115.2=172.8288-115.2=172.8): cheaper maintenance makes a bigger stock worth keeping.

Answer

K* = 576 when δ = 25%. K = 900 is optimal only if δ = 20%. The NDP-maximizing stock rises when depreciation falls.

Which input changed?

New factories, machines, roads, data centers
K.
Education, training, experience, better health
H.
More hours worked or more workers (immigration, a baby-boom cohort)
L. Raises total GDP, not GDP per person by itself.
A better recipe that gets more output from the same inputs
A (technology, TFP).
A question asks which K is best
Largest NDP, equivalently the last unit where MPK still exceeds δ.

Six-question check

1
Multiple choice

A country’s planners estimate GDP at five possible capital stocks: K = 200 gives 300, K = 400 gives 430, K = 600 gives 520, K = 800 gives 575 and K = 1,000 gives 610. Capital depreciates at 30% a year. Which capital stock gives the highest NDP?

2
Numeric answer

Output is Y=5KLY=5\sqrt{KL} with L=4L=4. The capital stock is 225 and the depreciation rate is 8%. What is NDP? Enter a whole number.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.
3
Multiple choice

Which statement describes diminishing marginal product of capital?

4
Multiple choice

A country keeps investing the same high share of GDP for decades, with no change in technology or the labor force. What happens to its growth rate?

5
Select all that apply

Which of these raise A (total factor productivity) rather than adding a factor of production? Select all that apply.

6
Numeric answer

Output is Y=8KY=8\sqrt{K} (other inputs fixed) and the depreciation rate is 5%. The capital stock rises from 400 to 441. By how much does NDP change? Enter the change to 2 decimal places.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.

MaizePrep is an independent study resource. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the University of Michigan. Course names and numbers are used only to describe which class the material covers. Every practice question is original, written in the style of the course.