MaizePrepECON 102
Midterm 1 · M1 · 6

Technology, growth accounting & policy

Sustained growth in rich countries needs rising technology, which also makes new capital worth building. Growth accounting backs out TFP as the residual. Policy cannot pull a lever on K or A; it shapes incentives to invest, invent and learn.

25 min

Build the model

Human capital is a particular worker’s ability to use the recipe; technology is the recipe itself. H is like A because it is knowledge, and like K because it must be accumulated through costly investment. Creative destruction (Schumpeter) is how a rich economy grows: new technology lets firms produce with fewer workers, old jobs disappear, and investment in K and H creates newer, more productive jobs. It can be painful for those displaced.

Growth accounting splits measured growth into contributions: %ΔY=%ΔA+αL%ΔL+αK%ΔK+…\%\Delta Y=\%\Delta A+\alpha_L\%\Delta L+\alpha_K\%\Delta K+\dots, where each weight is that factor’s share of income (about 2/3 labor, 1/3 capital in the US). Everything not explained by the factors is TFP growth, the residual. TFP is not labor productivity: output per hour can rise just because workers get more capital. Dale Jorgenson’s accounts: since 2000 world growth came mostly from non-IT capital; in the G7, TFP added little or nothing after 2005, and extra hours (immigration) plus non-IT capital did most of the work; emerging economies show large TFP gains, probably from borrowed technology.

Policy works on incentives: make investment profitable (simpler permits, tax incentives, infrastructure) and safe (rule of law, property rights, low corruption, the single most important difference for poor countries); support invention (patents against free riding, public R&D funding); support human capital (public education, health); open to trade (specialization, scale, competition) and FDI (more investment, technology and training, spillovers). The productivity slowdown since the 1970s has candidate explanations but no consensus.

Key ideas

Total factor productivity (TFP)

A in the production function: the productivity of all factors together, measured as the growth-accounting residual.

Labor productivity

Output per worker or per hour, Y/L. It rises with A, H or more capital per worker, so it is not the same as TFP.

Creative destruction

Old, less efficient jobs and firms are replaced by more productive ones as technology advances; frictional unemployment is the usual by-product.

Free-rider problem in R&D

Competitors copy inventions, so inventors cannot keep the gains. Patents and public R&D funding respond to it.

Rule of law

Courts and property rights that protect profits and assets from seizure. Without it investment does not happen even where returns look high.

Foreign direct investment (FDI)

Foreign firms build or buy plants. Adds investment beyond domestic saving and brings technology, training and spillovers.

Formulas

Growth accounting
%ΔY=%ΔA+αL%ΔL+αK%ΔK+αH%ΔH+αN%ΔN\%\Delta Y=\%\Delta A+\alpha_L\%\Delta L+\alpha_K\%\Delta K+\alpha_H\%\Delta H+\alpha_N\%\Delta N
TFP as the residual
%ΔA=%ΔY−αL%ΔL−αK%ΔK−…\%\Delta A=\%\Delta Y-\alpha_L\%\Delta L-\alpha_K\%\Delta K-\dots
Labor productivity growth
%ΔYL≈%ΔY−%ΔL\%\Delta\frac{Y}{L}\approx\%\Delta Y-\%\Delta L
With only K and L and weights summing to 1: %Δ(Y/L)≈%ΔA+αK(%ΔK−%ΔL)\%\Delta(Y/L)\approx\%\Delta A+\alpha_K(\%\Delta K-\%\Delta L).
On a log scale a constant growth rate is a straight line. The developed economy grows steadily with technology; the developing economy starts low, grows steeply while capital is scarce, then bends into the same slope.
Worked example

Back out TFP

Growth is described by %ΔY=%ΔA+0.4%ΔK+0.6%ΔL\%\Delta Y=\%\Delta A+0.4\%\Delta K+0.6\%\Delta L. Over a decade, output grew 3.2% a year, capital 4.0% and labor 0.5%. Find TFP growth and the largest source of growth.

  1. Capital’s contribution: 0.4×4.0=1.60.4\times4.0=1.6 points. Labor’s: 0.6×0.5=0.30.6\times0.5=0.3 points.

  2. TFP: %ΔA=3.2−1.6−0.3=1.3%\%\Delta A=3.2-1.6-0.3=1.3\% a year.

  3. Ranking: capital 1.6, TFP 1.3, labor 0.3.

Answer

TFP grew 1.3% a year; capital accumulation was the largest single source (1.6 of the 3.2 points).

Which policy, through which channel?

Make building a plant cheaper or more profitable (permits, tax incentives, roads, ports)
Investment → K.
Protect owners from seizure or corruption (courts, property rights, stability)
Investment becomes safe → K (the main reason many poor countries do not grow).
Patents, R&D grants, competition
A, and indirectly K and H because new technology makes them worth adding.
Public schools, scholarships, retraining, health care
H.
Open to trade or attract FDI
A through specialization, scale and competition; K through foreign investment; H through training and spillovers.

Six-question check

1
Numeric answer

Growth is described by %ΔY=%ΔA+0.35%ΔK+0.65%ΔL\%\Delta Y=\%\Delta A+0.35\%\Delta K+0.65\%\Delta L. Output grows 2.6% a year, capital 3.0% and labor 1.2%. What is TFP growth? Enter a percent to 2 decimal places.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.%
2
Multiple choice

With %ΔY=%ΔA+13%ΔK+23%ΔL\%\Delta Y=\%\Delta A+\tfrac13\%\Delta K+\tfrac23\%\Delta L, output grew 2.0% a year, hours 1.5% and capital 3.0%. What do TFP and labor productivity (output per hour) show?

3
Multiple choice

A country passes a law guaranteeing that profits of foreign-owned plants cannot be confiscated, and enforces it in independent courts. Through which channel does this mainly promote growth?

4
Select all that apply

Through which channels can foreign direct investment raise growth in a developing country? Select all that apply.

5
Multiple choice

According to the Jorgenson growth accounts shown in lecture, what drove growth in the G7 economies in the 2010s?

6
Multiple choice

Which of these was NOT among the explanations for the productivity slowdown discussed in lecture?

MaizePrep is an independent study resource. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the University of Michigan. Course names and numbers are used only to describe which class the material covers. Every practice question is original, written in the style of the course.