MaizePrepECON 102
Midterm 2 · M2 · 7

The open-economy model: three graphs

Saving and I + NCO set the real rate; the rate sets NCO; the real exchange rate adjusts until desired net exports equal NCO. Ask which curve shifts first.

32 min

Build the model

Graph 1 is the loanable-funds market with S=I+NCOS=I+NCO. Supply is still national saving. Demand is now I+NCOI+NCO: loanable funds buy domestic capital or foreign assets. NCO slopes down in the domestic rate, because a higher rr makes home assets more attractive than foreign ones.

Graph 2 plots the NCO curve against the same domestic rr. Read rr from graph 1 and find NCO. The NCO curve shifts only with the attractiveness of foreign assets relative to home: interest rates abroad, business climate abroad, turmoil abroad that sends money to a safe haven. Whenever the NCO curve shifts, demand in graph 1 shifts the same way by the same horizontal amount. The I part of demand shifts only with the productivity of domestic capital (technology, labor, regulation, taxes).

Graph 3 has the real exchange rate on the vertical axis and net exports on the horizontal. NCO is a vertical line at the value set in graph 2 (Mankiw’s “supply of dollars”). Desired NX slopes down, since a higher RER makes exports dearer and imports cheaper (Mankiw’s “demand for dollars”); it shifts with tastes for domestic versus foreign goods, foreign income, tariffs and quotas. The RER adjusts until NX=NCONX=NCO.

Four cases from lecture. Budget deficit: S left, r up, NCO down, RER up, NX down (the 1980s “twin deficits”). Investment boom: demand right through I, r up, then the same chain (late 1990s). Capital flight into the country: the NCO curve and demand shift left, r falls, NCO falls, RER rises, NX falls (the US as a safe haven since about 2014). Tariff: Desired NX shifts right, graphs 1 and 2 are untouched, RER rises and NX is unchanged; exports fall as much as imports. Because the RER is an equilibrium outcome, a government cannot weaken its currency by decree; it can only shift curves (raise saving by cutting the deficit, make investment less attractive, cut tariffs), each with its own costs.

Key ideas

Demand for loanable funds (open economy)

I+NCOI+NCO: funds used to buy domestic capital or foreign assets. Slopes down in the domestic real rate.

NCO curve

Net capital outflow at each domestic r. Shifts only with the attractiveness of foreign assets relative to home; a shift moves demand for loanable funds the same way.

Desired NX

Net exports desired at each real exchange rate; slopes down. Shifts with tastes, foreign income, tariffs and quotas.

Twin deficits

A budget deficit that raises r, attracts capital, appreciates the currency and produces a trade deficit, as in the 1980s US.

Safe haven

Capital flight from troubled economies into a trusted one: its r falls but its currency still appreciates.

Trade-policy result

With S and I unchanged, a tariff raises the RER and leaves NX unchanged; trade volume shrinks on both sides.

Formulas

Graph 1
S(r)=I(r)+NCO(r)S(r)=I(r)+NCO(r)
Supply: national saving. Demand: I + NCO.
Graph 3
NX(RER)=NCONX(RER)=NCO
The RER adjusts until desired net exports equal the NCO set upstream.
The chain
S, I  →  r  →  NCO  →  RER  →  NXS,\,I\;\to\;r\;\to\;NCO\;\to\;RER\;\to\;NX
Causation runs from saving and investment to the trade balance, not the other way.
Case 1, a budget deficit, graph 1: national saving shifts left from S₀ to S₁ against unchanged I + NCO; the real rate rises from r₀ to r₁.
Graph 2: the NCO curve does not shift. The higher r₁ moves the economy up along it, so NCO falls from NCO₀ to NCO₁ (more capital flows in).
Graph 3: the vertical NCO line moves left to NCO₁. The real exchange rate rises from RER₀ to RER₁ and net exports fall to NX₁, a movement along Desired NX.
Case 4, a tariff: Desired NX shifts right while the NCO line stays put (graphs 1 and 2 do not change). The RER rises and NX is unchanged.
Worked example

The lecture’s case 3: capital flight into the country

Before the shock, national saving is 500, investment 520 and NCO −20. Turmoil abroad makes foreign investors move funds into this country: at every domestic r, NCO falls by 50. In the new equilibrium saving is 490 and investment 530. Trace all three graphs and find the new NCO and NX.

  1. Which curve shifts first? The NCO curve shifts left (foreign assets are less attractive), and demand I+NCOI+NCO in graph 1 shifts left by the same 50.

  2. Graph 1: the real rate falls. Savers move down S (saving falls to 490); firms move down I (investment rises to 530). The I part of demand did not shift.

  3. New NCO =S−I=490−530=−40=S-I=490-530=-40: the capital inflow grows from 20 to 40.

  4. Graph 3: the NCO line moves left to −40, the RER rises, and NX falls to −40, a larger trade deficit.

Answer

r falls, investment rises, NCO and NX fall from −20 to −40, and the currency appreciates. Unlike the deficit and investment-boom cases, the real rate falls while the currency rises.

Which curve shifts first?

Budget deficit, tax on interest removed, more retirement saving
Graph 1 supply (S).
Domestic technology, regulation, corporate tax, labor force
Graph 1 demand through I only; the NCO curve does not shift, NCO changes by moving along it.
Interest rates or business climate abroad; turmoil abroad (safe-haven flows)
Graph 2 NCO curve, and graph 1 demand in the same direction.
Tastes for domestic versus foreign goods, foreign income, tariffs, quotas
Graph 3 Desired NX only; NX is unchanged and the RER adjusts.
r or the RER changes
Never a shift: a movement along curves caused by something else.

Six-question check

1
The open-economy model: three graphs

Households grow cautious and save more at every real interest rate. In the open-economy model, what happens to r, NCO, the RER and NX?

2
The open-economy model: three graphs

Households save more as a precaution, and at the same time the domestic corporate profit tax rises. Which statement describes the open-economy model correctly?

3
The open-economy model: three graphs

Rapid income growth abroad raises foreigners’ demand for this country’s exports at every real exchange rate. Saving and investment are unchanged. After adjustment:

4
The open-economy model: three graphs

Which events move the vertical NCO line in graph 3 (that is, change equilibrium NCO)? Select all that apply.

5
The open-economy model: three graphs

Over a year, an open economy’s real interest rate rises, its real exchange rate rises and its net exports fall, while desired national saving does not change. Which event best explains all three?

6
The open-economy model: three graphs

An open economy has national saving of 600 and investment of 680, with no net income from abroad. What are its net exports? Enter a signed whole number.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.

MaizePrep is an independent study resource. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the University of Michigan. Course names and numbers are used only to describe which class the material covers. Every practice question is original, written in the style of the course.