A bubble in one industry’s stocks led many firms to build plants in that industry. Which outcome follows when the bubble bursts?
Asset prices, bubbles & the 2008 crisis
Asset prices tell firms where to invest. A bubble sends the wrong signal; when it bursts, investment stops. In 2008 securitization turned a housing bust into a banking crisis.
Build the model
Businesses rarely value industries themselves; they watch which stocks Wall Street prices highly. If prices reflect fundamentals, that saves effort and steers saving to good projects. A speculative bubble is a price above fundamental value, either because the market misjudges profits or because buyers expect to resell to someone else at a higher price. One firm losing money is not a macro event; a recession follows when many firms follow the same wrong signal, investment stops suddenly, and lenders take losses.
Dot-com (2001). IT did raise US productivity growth from the mid-1990s, but the NASDAQ rose about fivefold in three years. The bubble burst in March 2000 and the index lost 78% by October 2002. Offices, servers and staff had been added for profits that never came; firms failed and investment stopped. The recession was mild.
Housing (2008–09). House prices rose for three reasons: low interest rates (future rents discounted less), speculation (buying to resell) and securitization. Banks used to hold each mortgage for decades, so they screened borrowers carefully. With securitization a bank pools many mortgages and sells a mortgage-backed security (MBS), gets its cash back and lends again; homebuyers gained access to the world’s savings. But a bank that sells a loan at once has little reason to screen it, while MBS buyers judged risk from default rates recorded when banks did screen. When prices fell about a quarter, many owners owed more than their houses were worth and stopped paying; MBS lost value, and banks that had bought them with borrowed money suffered large losses. The banking system stopped lending, so the channel that turns saving into investment broke: the deepest recession since the 1930s. The 2008 bailout saved the banks, not their owners, and the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act tightened rules.
Key ideas
- Speculative bubble
An asset price above its fundamental value, driven by expectations of further price rises rather than by expected cash flows.
- Asset prices as a signal
High prices in an industry tell firms its profits are expected to be high, which draws investment there.
- Dot-com bubble
Overvaluation of high-tech stocks in the late 1990s; the burst led to the mild 2001 recession.
- Securitization
Pooling many loans and selling bonds backed by their repayments; it let banks lend more but weakened their incentive to screen.
- Mortgage-backed security (MBS)
A bond paid from a pool of mortgages. Once defaults rose, MBS became “toxic paper” nobody wanted.
- Bank bailout (2008)
Public funds filled holes in bank balance sheets so lending could continue; owners lost their stakes, the banks survived.
Formulas
Trace the 2008 chain
Explain, step by step, how lower interest rates and securitization could turn a fall in house prices into an economy-wide recession.
Low rates raise the present value of future rents, so house prices rise; speculation adds a bubble on top.
A bank pools 1,000 mortgages, sells an MBS backed by them, gets its cash back and lends again, so mortgage credit expands and prices climb further.
Because the loans are sold at once, the bank screens less; MBS buyers price risk from a history of carefully screened loans, so MBS are overpriced.
Prices fall; borrowers who owe more than their homes are worth stop paying; the bank recovers a house worth less than the loan, and MBS lose value.
Banks that bought MBS with borrowed money take large losses and stop lending, so investment collapses well beyond construction.
Overbuilding plus a banking crisis: the saving-to-investment channel broke, which made 2008–09 far deeper than the 2001 dot-com recession.
Fundamentals or bubble?
Six-question check
Before securitization became common, why did banks screen mortgage borrowers carefully?
Which of these helped push US house prices up in the early 2000s, according to the lecture? Select all that apply.
Why were mortgage-backed securities overpriced before 2008?
Why was the 2008–09 recession much deeper than the 2001 dot-com recession?
An investor put 2,500 into a technology index fund at its peak; the index then lost 78% of its value. What is the investment worth after the fall? Enter a whole number.