MaizePrepECON 102
Midterm 2 · M2 · 6

Capital flows, the balance of payments & exchange rates

Export revenue must buy imports or foreign assets, so S − I = NX = NCO: a trade deficit is a capital inflow. The real exchange rate is the relative price that keeps them equal.

28 min

Build the model

With trade, Y=C+I+G+NXY=C+I+G+NX, so S−I=NXS-I=NX. Whatever a country saves but does not invest at home it lends abroad: net capital outflow NCO=S−I=NXNCO=S-I=NX. To import more than it exports, a country must borrow or sell assets; a trade surplus means it lends. Paying for an import is trade, not a capital flow.

The balance of payments records this on two sides: the current account (the trade balance plus net income from abroad, assumed zero unless stated) and the financial account (all capital flows). Countries lend to each other in three ways: foreign direct investment (building or buying production facilities to operate them), portfolio investment (stocks and bonds) and loans. FDI is hard to reverse and brings technology; portfolio flows are volatile, part safe-haven saving and part speculation, and can stop suddenly. The US has been a chronic borrower because of low private saving, budget deficits, strong investment opportunities and its role as a safe haven: all saving-and-investment stories, not stories about the quality of US goods. Most of that borrowing comes through portfolio investment: in the 2024 US financial account shown in lecture (see L6), portfolio flows were by far the largest net inflow, while direct investment was small.

In this course the nominal exchange rate ee is foreign currency per US dollar; a rise is an appreciation of the dollar. Demand for a currency rises when a country’s goods or assets become more attractive, so capital inflows appreciate it. The real exchange rate RER=eP/P∗RER=eP/P^* compares the price of domestic goods with foreign goods; a high RER makes domestic goods relatively expensive, which by the standard logic hurts producers (exporters) and helps consumers. Purchasing power parity says identical goods should cost the same everywhere, so RER=1RER=1. It fails in practice because many goods are non-tradable services, and transport costs and tastes differ; it works as a long-run benchmark and in high-inflation countries. Developing countries usually have RER below 1 because their services are cheap.

Key ideas

Net capital outflow (NCO)

Purchases of foreign assets by residents minus purchases of domestic assets by foreigners; equals S−IS-I and NX. Negative means a net capital inflow.

Current and financial accounts

The current account records trade (plus net foreign income); the financial account records capital flows. Their balances are equal apart from statistical error.

Foreign direct investment

Building or buying production facilities abroad to operate them; long-lived, hard to reverse, brings technology.

Portfolio investment

Buying foreign stocks and bonds without running the business; highly reversible and volatile.

Real exchange rate

RER=eP/P∗RER=eP/P^*: the price of domestic goods relative to foreign goods. Higher RER means domestic goods are relatively expensive.

Purchasing power parity

The theory that identical goods cost the same everywhere, so RER = 1. A long-run benchmark that fails for non-tradables.

Formulas

Open-economy identity
S−I=NX=NCOS-I=NX=NCO
Net foreign income is assumed zero unless the question says otherwise.
Real exchange rate
RER=e PP∗RER=\frac{e\,P}{P^*}
e: foreign currency per unit of domestic currency; P domestic and P* foreign price levels in their own currencies.
PPP exchange rate
RER=1  ⇒  e=P∗PRER=1\;\Rightarrow\;e=\frac{P^*}{P}
If PPP holds over time, e1=e0 (1+π∗)/(1+π)e_1=e_0\,(1+\pi^*)/(1+\pi).
Preview of the third graph of the open-economy model: when equilibrium NCO falls (more capital flows in), the vertical NCO line moves left, and the real exchange rate rises until desired net exports fall to the new NCO.
Worked example

Compute a real exchange rate and its PPP benchmark

One US dollar buys 0.92 euros. A basket costs 300 dollars in the US and 250 euros in the euro area. Find the real exchange rate of the dollar and the nominal rate PPP would predict.

  1. RER=eP/P∗=0.92×300/250=1.104RER=eP/P^*=0.92\times300/250=1.104.

  2. RER above 1: the US basket costs about 10.4% more than the euro basket once converted.

  3. PPP requires RER=1RER=1, so e=P∗/P=250/300=0.833e=P^*/P=250/300=0.833 euros per dollar.

  4. The actual rate of 0.92 is above that benchmark: the dollar is strong relative to PPP, good news for US consumers buying imports and bad news for US exporters.

Answer

RER ≈ 1.10; PPP would predict about 0.83 euros per dollar.

Inflow or outflow, from the US point of view?

A US firm builds or buys a plant abroad to operate it
Capital outflow (NCO up), foreign direct investment.
A foreign pension fund buys US Treasury bonds
Capital inflow (NCO down), portfolio investment.
A US bank lends to a foreign company
Capital outflow, a loan.
The US imports more than it exports
NX < 0, so NCO < 0: a net capital inflow of the same size.

Seven-question check

1
Capital flows, the balance of payments & exchange rates

A country’s exports are 210 and its imports are 250 this year, with no net income from abroad. Which statement must be true?

2
Capital flows, the balance of payments & exchange rates

From the US point of view, which are capital outflows? Select all that apply.

3
Capital flows, the balance of payments & exchange rates

The real exchange rate of the US dollar against the Canadian dollar is 0.90, and one US dollar buys 1.36 Canadian dollars. A basket of goods costs 250 US dollars in the US. Using RER = eP/P*, what does the same basket cost in Canada, in Canadian dollars? Enter to 2 decimal places.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.
4
Capital flows, the balance of payments & exchange rates

Purchasing power parity holds. Over a year the dollar goes from buying 20 Mexican pesos to buying 21.6, while US inflation is 2%. Using the exact PPP condition, what was Mexican inflation over the year? Enter a percent to 2 decimal places.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.%
5
Capital flows, the balance of payments & exchange rates

The Canadian dollar appreciates in real terms. Under the standard logic from lecture, which group in Canada is hurt?

6
Capital flows, the balance of payments & exchange rates

Why is the real exchange rate of most developing countries below 1?

7
Capital flows, the balance of payments & exchange rates

In a hypothetical country, the financial-account lines for one year, in billions of dollars, are: direct investment +40, portfolio investment −215, other investment (mostly loans) −35 and financial derivatives −6. A minus sign is a net inflow. What is the country’s net capital outflow? Enter a signed whole number of billions.

Math shortcuts are on for ECON 102. Type ^ then digits for powers, _ then digits for subscripts.

MaizePrep is an independent study resource. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the University of Michigan. Course names and numbers are used only to describe which class the material covers. Every practice question is original, written in the style of the course.