Theorist comparison
Two readings side by side: thesis, key concepts, what to look for and what not to infer. Practice mode covers one column.
Pairs the guide contrasts
Practice
CompareMarx Pande
Unit
MarxUnit IV · Political Economy & Power
PandeUnit IV · Political Economy & Power
Work
MarxThe Communist Manifesto — Bourgeois and Proletarians
PandeManufacturing the Perfect Mother-Worker — Wombs in Labor, chapter 4
Thesis
MarxCapitalism organizes antagonistic class relations around ownership and wage labor while continually transforming production and social life.
PandeThe perfect surrogate, "cheap, docile, selfless and nurturing," is not found ready-made: fertility clinics and surrogacy hostels produce her through a disciplinary project that works through language and metaphor and through control of her body. It exploits the duality of worker-producer and mother-reproducer, manipulated at every stage, from recruitment to the hostel, in ways that most benefit the clinic.
Key concepts
Marx
- Bourgeoisie The class that owns and controls the means of production and employs wage labor.
- Proletariat Workers who must sell their labor power to live because they lack productive property sufficient to support themselves.
- Class antagonism Owners and workers occupy opposed positions over control of production and the distribution of its benefits.
- Revolutionizing production Competitive pressure continually transforms production, markets, and established social relationships.
Pande
- Mother-worker duality The surrogate must be a disciplined contract worker who hands over the baby when the contract ends, and at the same time a nurturing mother attached to the baby and a selfless one who "will not negotiate the payment received." Being a good mother often conflicts with being a good worker.
- Recruitment through brokers Brokers, often midwives, go village to village and door to door; they recruited more than half of Pande's interviewees. They look for mothers "in desperate need of money" for their own children: being a mother is both a medical requirement and "a mechanism to control her as a worker."
- Counseling and the contract Counseling gives illiterate surrogates only selected information, and the contract is in English, which almost none can read; a counselor translates a few points (hand over the baby, no claims on it, no one responsible for a death, payment in installments). Staff stress that she is "merely a vessel," which conceals her value even though demand for surrogates exceeds supply.
- The gift metaphor The counselor's rule: "don't treat it like a business; instead, treat it like God's gift to you. Don't be greedy." In North America surrogates are cast as "gift-giving angels"; here surrogacy is God's gift to needy mothers, and the underlying instruction is not to negotiate wages.
- Mystification Inadequate, patronizing counseling "further mystifies the unfamiliar technological process for the surrogates," leading to the deification of the process and the doctor, the "everyday divine." It is the surrogates' own view of the clinic, not outsiders failing to see their labor.
- Hostel discipline Dormitory-style hostels and clinic rooms keep surrogates under constant surveillance, with timetables, ranking by stage of pregnancy and by the clients' nationality, and self-supervision of everyday life. The hostel-as-home metaphor dilutes the labor and justifies the surveillance.
What to look for
MarxWho owns productive assets? Who must sell labor? How is surplus taken, and how does competition transform production?
PandeHow do brokers, counseling, the contract, the hostel and the gift metaphor manufacture a worker who is also a selfless mother?
Do not infer
MarxHigh income alone establishes bourgeois class position.
PandeA paid contract makes bargaining equal, or the surrogates are passive victims with no choices.
- Class is not income. The lecture repeated that class is "your relationship to production," not income, lifestyle or status.
- Commodity fetishism versus mystification. Commodity fetishism (Marx lecture) is about consumers: the labor and suffering behind a product disappear from view. Pande's mystification is about the surrogates themselves: inadequate counseling makes the technology and the doctor seem divine. Do not use one for the other.
- Which way the gift runs. The professor said the gift metaphor "is where everybody f—s up on the exam." In North America the surrogate is the gift-giving angel; in Pande's clinic surrogacy is God's gift to needy mothers, and the lecture added that the intended parents get cast as the helpers. Either way the effect is to discourage negotiating.
- Marx and Pande are connected, not identical. Marx gives the ownership relation and alienation; Pande specifies how a reproductive worker is produced through the mother-worker duality. Use a mechanism from each instead of saying both involve exploitation.
Connect Marx and Pande: the professor said on Oct 27 that the connection "is gonna be on the exam, it always is." Know Pande's mechanisms (hospital control, the contract, the brokers, the doctor, mystification) and the gift metaphor (Oct 29).
Used in
Midterm · Thinking SociologicallyMidterm · Epistemology & MethodsMidterm · Race-Making & RepresentationMidterm · Interaction, Disability & GenderMidterm · Midterm Review: Compare Across UnitsFinal · Political Economy & PowerFinal · Education & Institutional ReproductionFinal · Trauma as Cultural CapitalFinal · Silence, Religion & Cultural CritiqueFinal · Agency & Social Change