MaizePrepSOC 100
Midterm · Unit II

Epistemology & Methods

Sampson and Wilson measure community structure from a distance; Bourgois immerses himself in East Harlem's crack economy. Same ontology, different epistemology, and the cause, mechanism and outcome chain the review lecture said students miss.

35 min

Paradigms toolkit (Sep 15-17 lectures)

Paradigm

A set of assumptions about what counts as truth, which a field's research works within; many anomalies over time produce a paradigm shift.

Example Evolution in biology: a study does not have to prove it first.

Epistemology

What counts as knowledge and how we know it.

Example Is a crime rate or a resident's account the better evidence about violence?

Ontology

What counts as reality. The lecture's focus was the ontology of violence: does it come from inside a person or from social conditions?

Example Both readings reject "some people are born violent."

Positivism and post-positivism

Real knowledge is observable and measured from a distance. Post-positivists accept the limits of measurement but keep an objective reality, replicable results and proxies for what cannot be observed directly.

Example Poverty rates by race as a proxy for the effects of structural racism.

Interpretivism and critical research

Knowledge is valid if it captures actors' meanings and perspectives; critical research also exposes power and asks what violence means in the social world.

Example Asking what a reputation for violence does for a dealer, not only how often assaults occur.

Robert J. Sampson & William Julius Wilson

Toward a Theory of Race, Crime, and Urban Inequality

The claim

Racial differences in violent crime come from structural differences among communities, not from race, individual traits or a self-sustaining culture of violence. Segregation and deindustrialization concentrate disadvantage, which weakens community social organization.

Social disorganization
The mechanism: a community's inability to realize common values and regulate behavior through its relationships (weak ties, little participation in organizations, nobody supervising youth).
Concentrated disadvantage
The structural cause: poor Black families are far more likely than poor white families to live among other poor families. In none of the 171 largest U.S. cities did Black residents live in ecological equality with whites. The methodological point the lecture stressed follows: large-area rates, such as county averages, can mask these local concentrations.
The individualistic fallacy
In the reading's words, "the often-invoked assumption that individual-level causal relations necessarily generate individual-level correlations." Research done only at the individual level rarely asks whether its results are spurious, confounded with community-level processes; a Black and a white child in the same family situation rarely grow up in similar communities.
Social isolation, not culture of violence
Structure comes first; residents adapt to constraints and lose contact with mainstream institutions. Violence becomes tolerated, not valued, and would fade if structural inequality fell.
Apply it

A state report shows one county with a modest homicide rate, but two tracts inside it, both hit by plant closures, account for most of the killings. Use the cause, mechanism and outcome chain, and explain why the county average misleads.

Sampson and Wilson's causal chain (the lecture's three levels)

LevelWhat it isExamples
1. Structural conditions (cause)Features of the neighborhood that make disorganization possible. Not social disorganization itself.Segregation, deindustrialization, joblessness, concentrated poverty, residential instability
2. Social disorganization (mechanism)The process linking those conditions to crime: the community cannot realize common values or regulate behavior.Weak friendship and kinship ties, little participation in churches, teams and after-school programs, no one supervising youth
3. Crime and delinquency (outcome)The result, which is not disorganization itself.Higher rates of robbery, violence and homicide, especially among youth

Check: Sampson and Wilson

1
Unit II · Sampson & Wilson

After two factories close, church membership falls, block clubs dissolve and no adults watch the corner after school; youth robberies then rise. In Sampson and Wilson's chain, which element is social disorganization?

2
Unit II · Sampson & Wilson

A state agency ranks metro areas by their average violent-crime rate and denies a violence-prevention grant to one metro whose average is low, although two of its neighborhoods have very high rates. Which Sampson and Wilson argument does this illustrate?

3
Unit II · Comparing methods

Which statement correctly compares Sampson and Wilson with Bourgois?

4
Unit II · Sampson & Wilson

A council member argues that violence persists in a neighborhood because residents value it. How would Sampson and Wilson respond?

5
Unit II · Sampson & Wilson

Which explanation of Black crime do Sampson and Wilson criticize as an individual-level psychological concept?

Philippe Bourgois

Violating Apartheid in the United States (In Search of Respect, ch. 1)

The claim

Through years of immersion in East Harlem's crack economy, Bourgois shows street culture and violence as responses to structural exclusion, a de facto apartheid. Their meaning can only be grasped up close, through immersion rather than distance.

Ethnography and interpretivism
Immersion, observation, interviews and field notes over years. Knowledge counts if it captures the meaning and perspective of social actors; distance produces misrecognition.
Hidden apartheid
Segregation that is illegal in law but enforced in fact: by police who assume a white man in El Barrio is lost, an addict or an officer, and by a racist "common sense" that keeps outsiders away.
Cultural capital
Bourdieu's term for the know-how a field rewards. Ray thrives in the street economy but cannot handle IDs, permits and paperwork, so his skills do not transfer to legal society.
Respect and functional violence
In the underground economy, a reputation for violence ("juice") is an investment that brings protection and loyalty; it is rational inside that field, not senseless.
Apply it

A researcher who moves into a public-housing complex is treated as a caseworker by residents and as a suspect by patrol officers. Explain what each reaction reveals about hidden apartheid, and why Bourgois would record it as data about the field.

Ethnography's critics and the answer (Sep 17 lecture)

Misrecognition

Failing to see or correctly value a group's identity and contributions. Bourgois's charge against research done only from a distance: numbers alone distort.

Example Reading a neighborhood only through its homicide rate.

White coat effect

The researcher's effect on the research: participants shape answers to what they think a higher-status researcher wants.

Example A respondent downplays drug use to a professor.

Studying down

Researchers from advantaged groups studying marginalized communities, rarely the reverse.

Example Rich scholars study the poor; few study the rich.

Reflexivity and positionality

The lecture's answer to the critics: keep reflecting on and stating your position and how it shapes what you see. At the Oct 13 review the professor said of positionality and reflexivity: "I don't think that shows up... No it doesn't." Know it as background, not as a likely question.

Example "I am a white man seeing this," written into the analysis.

Choose the lens, then identify the mechanism

Thinker / lensWhat to look forDo not infer
Sampson & WilsonCommunity-level structural conditions and social organization; race-specific comparisons; data that hide local conditions.Poverty and crime are the same thing, or a culture that values violence explains the pattern.
BourgoisMeaning, respect and violence inside a field; hidden apartheid; cultural capital; the researcher's own position.Immersion means abandoning analysis, or his findings show crime is a free individual choice.
Worked example

Designing two studies of the same problem

A city asks why youth violence is much higher in one of its neighborhoods than another with similar median income. Sketch how Sampson and Wilson and how Bourgois would study it, and what each could and could not tell the city.

  1. Shared starting point (ontology): the violence comes from conditions in and around the neighborhood, not from the residents' nature.

  2. Sampson and Wilson: measure block-level conditions separately by race (joblessness, family disruption, residential turnover, participation in organizations) and test which predict youth violence. Do not rely on a citywide or median-income comparison, which can hide concentrated disadvantage.

  3. Their result could show that the higher-violence neighborhood has weaker social organization, for example fewer supervising adults, and point to structural causes like plant closures.

  4. Bourgois: spend years in the neighborhood, build trust, observe and interview young people and dealers, and record what respect and violence mean there and how police and institutions treat residents. Reflect on how the researcher's position shapes access.

  5. His result could show why a young person carries a weapon (protection, reputation) and how exclusion from legal work and schools pushes people toward the street economy.

  6. Limits: the statistical design cannot capture meaning; the ethnography cannot estimate rates for the whole city.

Answer

Use both. The statistical design shows which community conditions predict the gap; the ethnography explains what violence means and does in daily life. They agree on what violence is and differ on how to know it.

Check: Bourgois and the comparison

1
Unit II · Bourgois

A white volunteer tutor in a predominantly Black neighborhood is stopped by patrol officers several times a month, asked whether he is lost and told to "find somewhere safer to live." What does Bourgois call what the officers are enforcing?

2
Unit II · Bourgois

A man runs a profitable informal auto-repair network with a dozen workers, but every attempt to open a licensed garage collapses at the permit forms and inspections. Which Bourgois concept fits?

3
Unit II · Ethnography's critics

In a study of a food pantry, volunteers tell a visiting university team that they never turn anyone away, but a resident who helps run the pantry hears them describe, over months, the families they quietly send elsewhere. Which critique of research from the Sep 17 lecture does the gap illustrate?

4
Unit II · Bourgois

True or false: Bourgois argues that quantitative findings like Sampson and Wilson's are false.

5
Unit II · Bourgois

True or false: for Bourgois, a reputation for violence in the crack economy can be a rational investment inside that field.

MaizePrep is an independent study resource. It is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the University of Michigan. Course names and numbers are used only to describe which class the material covers. Every practice question is original, written in the style of the course.