Before meeting a professor, a student puts on a blazer and plans a formal email sign-off. In Goffman's terms, what are these?
Interaction, Disability & Gender
Symbolic interactionism from Goffman's face-work through Clare's mountain, West and Zimmerman's doing gender, Nordberg's bacha posh and Pascoe's fag discourse, with the lecture-only Mead and Connell material.
The self and the expressive order (Sep 29 lecture)
- Symbolic interactionism
People act toward things on the basis of what they mean in context, and meanings are adjusted through feedback. The same wink means different things at home, in a club and on the subway.
Example Silence in a political argument is still read as a line.
- Mead's I and me (lecture only)
The I is the self as subject, acting; the me is the self as object, seen and judged. The self is not the body.
Example "I said good morning" (I) versus "why was I so awkward?" (me).
- Self-consciousness (lecture only)
The mental act of the I turning its attention toward the me: an ongoing awareness of yourself in relation to others, not just thinking.
Example Rehearsing how you looked to the room after you spoke.
- Expressive order
The informal "traffic rules" of interaction. Everyone commits to their own face and others' (self-respect and considerateness), and lines are given working acceptance. Most social order runs on these rules, not on laws.
Example Letting a self-proclaimed expert's claims pass to keep the conversation going.
On Face-Work
Every encounter rests on face: the positive social value a person claims through the line others assume they are taking. People cooperate to maintain one another's face through avoidance and corrective work, an informal expressive order that keeps social life orderly.
- Line and face
- A line is the pattern of verbal and nonverbal acts by which you express your view of the situation (the glasses you wear to an interview). Face is the positive value others grant you for that line, located in the flow of the encounter, not in you.
- Wrong face and out of face
- Wrong face: information comes out that cannot be integrated into your line, but you can still play it. Out of face: you can no longer sustain any line expected in the situation.
- Avoidance process
- Protecting face by staying away from threatening encounters, steering off risky topics, hedging claims or tactfully not "seeing" a slip.
- Corrective process
- When a threat is too obvious to ignore: challenge, offering, acceptance, thanks. If no correction works, someone has to exit.
A new hire who claimed fluency in a language is asked by a client to translate and freezes. Locate the line, the moment it becomes wrong face, the point of out of face, and a corrective sequence that could restore order.
Check: face-work and the self
At a dinner, a guest who presents himself as a wine expert mispronounces a famous region; no one comments, and he keeps going. Later the host hands him the list and asks him to choose, and he admits he knows almost nothing about wine. Where is the guest out of face?
Which sequence matches Goffman's corrective process?
A manager expecting hard questions about layoffs schedules the all-hands meeting to end early and fills the agenda with good news. Which kind of face-work is this?
A moment after giving a toast, someone replays in her head how she must have sounded to the guests. In the lecture's account of Mead, what is she doing?
The Mountain (Exile and Pride, ch. 1)
The mountain is a metaphor for dominant standards of success and normality that disabled people are pushed to conquer. The supercrip story treats disability as tragedy and overcoming as heroism; Clare refuses it in favor of access, community and the body as home.
- Impairment versus disability
- Impairment is the body (Clare's shaking hands, slow speech, balance). Disability is social: the gap between bodily capacities and what an environment built for normal bodies demands.
- Supercrip
- The story that disabled people must overcome their impairments; ordinary acts are applauded as extraordinary because the body is stigmatized, and the focus leaves access and exclusion.
- Internalized supercripdom
- Taking the hero narrative into one's own mind: Clare equated competence with invulnerability and risked a dangerous climb. The lecture calls it face-work when it's internalized.
- The mountain
- Clare lists what it stands for: the grind of "capitalism, patriarchy, white supremacy," glass ceilings, the class ladder, assimilation and "that phantom called normality"; a disciplinary tool. On Mount Adams she first decides turning around was "more about impairment than disability," then refuses the neat split: her experience of impairment "has been so shaped by disability" that she cannot separate them, and part of it was her own desire to climb.
A wheelchair user's commute is featured on the evening news as "inspiring" while the station's own building has no working elevator. Use Clare to name the supercrip frame and redirect the story to access.
What disabled people disrupt (Oct 1 lecture)
- Productivity
"Able-bodied" emerged with industrial capitalism, defining ability by capacity for productive labor; disability became the label for people who could not work efficiently for employers.
Example Economic worth tied to bodily function.
- Independence and interdependence
Disabled people are stigmatized as dependent, but everyone relies on others and on institutions; activists make interdependence visible as the normal way of living.
Example Nobody becomes a doctor alone; institutions train and carry you.
- Norms of speed and silence
Society's pace and its link between quiet and respectability are set by able bodies; extra time, pauses, stimming and assistive devices expose that. "Silence protects able-bodied comfort, not collective well-being."
Example Classrooms and offices that treat noise as disruption.
- Tactful blindness as exclusion
Looking away from a disabled person's difference as if it did not happen feels polite but is a learned form of social exclusion.
Example Never mentioning a colleague's impairment and never inviting him along.
- Infantilization and desexualization (lecture only)
Disabled people are imagined as childlike and therefore not sexual at all; partners are judged differently by gender (a man's desire stays visible, a woman's is read as pity). The professor said this lecture-only argument will be tested.
Example Surprise or disapproval when disabled people date.
Doing Gender (assigned: the opening pages through accountability)
Gender is not a trait, role or display but a routine accomplishment done in interaction: managing conduct in light of normative conceptions for one's sex category, under constant accountability. Because it is omnirelevant, doing gender is unavoidable.
- Sex, sex category, gender
- Sex: classification by socially agreed biological criteria. Sex category: the public proxy for sex, sustained by identificatory displays. Gender: managing situated conduct as a normal woman or man of that category.
- Critique of display and role theory
- Goffman's gender display puts gender at the periphery of interaction; role theory ties it to a site, but gender has no specific site and cannot be left like a role.
- Accountability
- People are held accountable to their sex category in virtually any activity, and design their actions with an eye to how they will be characterized. The lecture: this is Goffman's face-work under another name.
- Agnes
- Garfinkel's case: a trans woman who had to consciously learn what most women do without noticing, which makes visible the work of doing gender.
A father who packs elaborate lunches is praised as "amazing" while a mother doing the same is unremarked, and a mother who forgets is judged. Use accountability to explain the asymmetry, and say which layer, sex category or gender, is being assessed.
Gender as a social construct (Oct 6-8 lectures)
- Four meanings of "socially constructed"
Gender is not universal (no expression is shared by every society), it is a system of power (it stratifies access), it is a social practice (done continuously), and social processes have historically superseded biological determinism.
Example Single mothers are far more likely than single fathers to fall into poverty.
- Intersex, trans, gender non-conforming
Intersex: differences between external and internal sex characteristics. Trans: crossing gender norms to live in a new gendered way, with no genital difference implied. Gender non-conforming: departing from norms while identifying with one's gender. The professor: do not confuse intersex and trans.
Example Most infant intersex surgeries assigned girls.
- Medicalization
Defining human differences as medical problems. "Medicine didn't discover trans people; they produced the categories," offering treatment while classifying it as illness.
Example Homosexuality removed from the DSM as gender-identity diagnoses were added.
- Biopower and naming
Institutions deciding which bodies live, die and in what ways; paternalistic medical knowledge claims to know a patient's gender better than the patient. Renaming intersex as a "disorder" turns variation into pathology.
Example Georgiann Davis's unnecessary surgery and the information withheld from her.
The Underground Girls of Kabul, ch. 1 "Bacha Posh" and ch. 16 "The Warrior"
Afghan families raise some daughters as boys because land, wealth and reputation run through sons in a patriarchal order. Adults who refuse to return to womanhood argue for freedom, not trans identity: birth sex is a reality, and gender and freedom are ideas.
- Bacha posh
- A girl dressed and raised as a boy, often until puberty. The cause is socioeconomic: a son is mandatory for a family's standing, inheritance and safety, and men are shamed for lacking male lineage.
- Socioeconomic, not innate
- The lecture's stress: this has nothing to do with being born a certain way or inner gender feelings, as U.S. debates assume; it answers social conditions.
- Gender and freedom as ideas
- Nordberg: see birth sex as a reality, and gender and freedom as ideas. Who would not walk out in disguise if the alternative was living as a prisoner?
- Freedom as the bigger idea
- The warriors of ch. 16 reject the trans label; they want the access the male category gives. The lecture's claim: gender does not matter until you are free.
In a fictional town where only men may run a market stall, a widow's eldest daughter keeps the stall by dressing as a boy and refuses to stop at sixteen. Explain the cause with Nordberg and why calling her trans misreads the argument.
Dude, You're a Fag (ch. 3, Adolescent Male Homophobia)
Fag discourse is less about sexual orientation than about enforcing masculinity. Any boy can be cast as the fag for failing at competence, heterosexuality or toughness. The label is raced and classed, and it is reinforced by school institutions.
- Fag discourse
- A disciplinary mechanism of gender regulation: the fag is an abject position any boy can be pushed into and pass on, which is why it terrifies all boys and is a discourse rather than an identity.
- Repudiatory ritual
- Imitating the fag to prove you are not one: everyone knows it is a joke, it is dropped right away, and the label moves on.
- Gay versus fag
- Gay attaches to a marginalized masculinity a boy can hold and still be masculine; the fag is subordinated masculinity, the failure to be a man.
- Raced, classed, spatially contingent
- The specter of the fag is implicitly white (among some African American boys, whiteness stood in for it), so K.J. could dance without the label while Ricky could not; drama spaces and PE classes shape where it bites.
On a middle-school bus, eighth-graders mimic a lisping voice and tell sixth-graders to run from whoever is "it," then switch to praising a quarterback. Identify the repudiatory ritual and explain why the target's actual sexuality is beside the point.
Connell's four relations of masculinity (Oct 8 lecture; a lens on Pascoe, not assigned)
- Hegemonic masculinity
The most culturally exalted form, holding the most power; historically specific and abstract enough that few men meet it, though those closest hold power.
Example Describe a CEO and you have described hegemonic masculinity.
- Complicit masculinity
Men who do not embody the ideal but do not challenge it, because they benefit from it.
Example Boys who never use fag discourse but sustain it through silence.
- Marginalized masculinity
Another identity, especially race or class, interferes with access to the hegemonic ideal. In Pascoe, gay can work this way.
Example Black masculinity cast as hypersexual, which also shields boys from the fag label.
- Subordinated masculinity
The bottom of the gender order: the feminized "ultimate sissy." In Pascoe, the fag.
Example A boy who cries after a loss labeled for weeks.
Choose the lens, then identify the mechanism
| Thinker / lens | What to look for | Do not infer |
|---|---|---|
| Goffman | Line, face, wrong face and out of face, avoidance and the four corrective moves; face-work as informal social order. | Face is a possession, or face-work is a conscious goal rather than a background condition. |
| Clare | Impairment versus disability; supercrip and internalized supercripdom; the mountain as a disciplinary standard; access. | Disability is only a private bodily misfortune, or praise is harmless. |
| West & Zimmerman | Sex, sex category and gender; accountability in any activity; the critique of display and role theories. | Gender is a role you can leave, a display at the edges of interaction, or a free individual performance. |
| Nordberg | Sons required for standing and inheritance; adults who refuse to return; freedom as the bigger idea. | Bacha posh is a trans identity or an expression of inner gender feelings. |
| Pascoe | Fag discourse as discipline; repudiatory ritual; gay (marginalized) versus fag (subordinated); race and institutions. | Fag discourse is only homophobia aimed at gay boys. |
Following one encounter from line to repair
At a team dinner, a new analyst tells colleagues he "basically grew up sailing." Later someone mentions the boat club's annual race; he asks what a "jib" is. A senior partner laughs: "I thought you grew up sailing?" He goes quiet. Walk through Goffman's concepts and then ask how gender accountability might change the scene.
Line: the sailing story is part of the line he takes, an image of ease with an upper-class pastime. Face is the value the table grants him for it.
Wrong face: the jib question is information that cannot be integrated into his line, but no one remarks on it, so he can keep playing it.
Out of face: the partner's challenge makes the line unsustainable; he has no ready line for the situation.
Corrective process: the challenge has happened. An offering ("I meant I grew up near the water" with a self-deprecating joke), the table's acceptance (laughter, a change of subject) and his thanks would restore the expressive order. If no correction works, someone exits.
Note the emotional charge: the burn of embarrassment is how the expressive order controls conduct, even though nothing material was lost.
Gender accountability: West and Zimmerman would add that the same bluff may be judged differently for a woman or a man. Whether he is laughed at, pitied or forgiven depends on how his conduct is characterized for his sex category.
The sailing story is a line, the jib question creates wrong face, the partner's remark puts him out of face, and a challenge, offering, acceptance and thanks sequence repairs it. W&Z add that how his slip is judged is also shaped by accountability to his sex category.
Check: Clare and doing gender
A student with low vision reads comfortably with large print, but the online exam platform cannot enlarge text and she fails a timed quiz. Using Clare's distinction, where is the disability?
A local paper praises a man who uses a prosthetic leg for "refusing to let his disability stop him" from attending his daughter's recital. What does Clare call this frame?
Disability activists argue that nobody gets through school, work or medicine without relying on other people and institutions. Which norm of able-bodiedness from the lecture does this challenge?
True or false: for Clare, internalized supercripdom means taking the hero story into one's own self-image and pushing the body to prove it.
A shopper with very short hair and a deep voice is called "sir" by a cashier, though she is a woman. In West and Zimmerman's framework, which layer is the cashier reading?
Check: gender, freedom and masculinity
Why do West and Zimmerman reject treating gender as a role?
Which explanation matches Nordberg's account of why Afghan families create a bacha posh?
An openly gay, athletic and popular boy is rarely targeted at school, while a straight boy who cries after losing a game is called a fag for weeks. What does Pascoe's analysis explain?
True or false: Pascoe finds that fag discourse works the same way across racial groups at the school she studied.
A man never mocks anyone, but he stays silent while his workplace rewards aggressive, dominant men, and he enjoys the advantages that come with it. Which of Connell's relations does he illustrate?