Residents describe a hierarchy as just common sense without anyone threatening them. Which evidence would most strengthen a hegemony interpretation?
Agency & Social Change
Lears on hegemony, consent and contradictory consciousness (Dec 1); Tufekci on the networked public sphere (Dec 3). Reading-led until the lectures happen.
The Concept of Cultural Hegemony: Problems and Possibilities
Lears develops Gramsci's account of rule through cultural leadership and consent while emphasizing that subordinate consciousness is contradictory and domination is incomplete.
- Cultural hegemony
- Dominant groups secure consent through cultural leadership that makes a particular social order appear legitimate or ordinary.
- Common sense
- Historically formed, often inconsistent assumptions that make arrangements feel self-evident rather than political.
- Contradictory consciousness
- People may repeat dominant assumptions while their practical experience supports different understandings and resistance.
- Counter-hegemony
- Collective efforts challenge dominant meanings and build alternative understandings; consent is never necessarily complete.
Residents say housing outcomes always reflect effort yet organize against rent increases they describe as unfair. Read the tension as contradictory consciousness rather than proof that residents have no agency.
A Networked Public — Twitter and Tear Gas, chapter 1
Movements are attempts to intervene in the public sphere, and technologies reshape that sphere. The twenty-first-century public sphere is digitally networked: online and offline publics intertwined, which changes who can broadcast, find one another and document wrongdoing, while authorities shift from outright censorship to new ways of controlling attention.
- Public sphere
- Habermas's "people gathered together as a public, articulating the needs of society with the state." There is no single uniform public sphere: counterpublics form to oppose the hegemonic one, and access (male-only coffeehouses, wealthy salons, literacy) has always been unequal.
- Imagined communities
- Benedict Anderson's term, which Tufekci uses: mass media like newspapers let people who will never meet think of themselves as one group, as shared national languages did.
- Networked public sphere
- Tufekci's shorthand for the reconfigured whole: publics online and offline, "all intertwined, multiple, connected," and global. It does not mean online-only.
- Visibility and connection
- Ordinary people can now broadcast, connect with strangers and document wrongdoing beyond "authorities said, activists claimed." Where media were censored, people could learn that their neighbors shared their grievances: "If you cannot find people, you cannot form a community with them."
- New tactics of control
- Authorities still try to control the public sphere, but "producing information glut, inducing confusion and distraction, and mobilizing counter-movements, rather than imposing outright censorship" are becoming their playbook.
A neighborhood network spreads eyewitness video excluded from local broadcasts, and within days the hashtag is flooded with unrelated posts and rumors. Identify the change in visibility and connection, and the newer form of control Tufekci describes.
Choose the lens, then identify the mechanism
| Thinker / lens | What to look for | Do not infer |
|---|---|---|
| Lears reading Gramsci | Cultural leadership, consent, common sense, and contradictions in consciousness. | Hegemony means everyone believes exactly the same thing or force disappears. |
| Tufekci | The public sphere and counterpublics; the networked public sphere; visibility and connection; control through information glut rather than censorship. | The networked public sphere is online-only, or digital tools erase race, gender and class. |
What Tufekci's chapter traces
| Development | What it changed | The chapter's caution |
|---|---|---|
| Mass media and national languages | Imagined communities: strangers think of themselves as one public | Access to broadcasting depended on owning or reaching a station or newspaper |
| Coffeehouses, salons and city squares | Public spheres where non-family members debated common affairs | Many were male-only or limited to the wealthy and literate |
| Digital networks | Ordinary people can broadcast, connect and document wrongdoing | Race, gender and class are reproduced online; it is not online-only |
| Authorities' response | Control shifts toward information glut, confusion and counter-movements | The aim of controlling the public sphere stays the same |
Apply it: Lears and Tufekci
Tufekci uses the term networked public sphere. Which description matches her definition?
Under a regime whose newspapers never reported protests, many people did not know whether their neighbors also opposed the government. What changed when digital networks spread, in Tufekci's account?